A team of scientists argue that a One Health approach to plant health is vital if we are to sustainably feed a growing population expected to reach 10 billion by 2050.
The researchers, who published a commentary in the CABI Agriculture and Bioscience journal, suggest that a One Health perspective can help optimize net benefits from plant protection to realize greater food security and nutrition gains.
One Health is an integrated, unifying approach that aims to sustainably balance and optimize the health of people, animals and ecosystems. It recognizes that the health of humans, domestic and wild animals, plants and the wider environment are closely linked and inter-dependent.
Dr. Vivian HoffmannSenior Research Fellow at the International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI), is a lead author of the commentary which focuses on two primary trade-offs that lie at the interface of plant health with animal, ecosystem and human health.
Dr Hoffmann and the researchers say that protecting plant health through use of agrochemicals versus minimizing risks to human health and antimicrobial and insecticide resistance is one consideration.
While another, the scientists argue, is ensuring food security by prioritizing the health of crops to maximise agricultural production versus protecting environmental systems.
The commentary, which stems from a webinar organized by CGIAR and attended by over 200 participants from around the world, discusses challenges and opportunities for advancement associated with each of these trade-offs – by taking account of how the priorities and constraints of stakeholders may vary by gender.
It stresses that building the capacity of regulatory bodies in low and middle-income countries to conduct cost-benefit analysis has the potential to improve decision-making in the context of these and other multi-dimensional trade-offs.
The webinar included presentations on sustainable intensification, benefits to plant health, and risks to human health, of using manure and wastewater to fertilize food crops; Tanzania’s experience with pesticide regulation’ management of plant associated food safety hazards where regulatory capacity is weak, and the role of gender in One Health.
Dr Hoffmann said, “Increasing crop yields through healthy plants is critical to achieving food security for a global growing population. But agricultural production also poses threats to environmental processes that underpin human health.”
The commentary, for instance, highlights that agriculture contributes 34% of greenhouse gas emissions, consumes 84% of fresh water and is the single biggest source of eutrophication causing nitrogen and phosphorus pollution in aquatic systems.
“Interventions to plant health practices that balance ecological concerns and food production will need to consider the constraints, needs, and motivations of farmers, including those mediated by gender,” Dr Hoffmann added.
Webinar participants made the point that farmers and other stakeholders of limited means, and women in particular, may not have the luxury of prioritizing environmental sustainability.
Dr Hoffmann said, “These points to the need for external financing, perhaps through international green development or climate funds, to promote ecologically sustainable agricultural practices.”
The scientists also believe that trade-offs are expected to depend critically on the intensity of exposure to environmental hazards, food security status, and levels – all of which vary across countries. There is therefore a need, they say, for context-specific analysis and, as such, greater capacity for cost-benefit analysis in low land middle-income countries as a matter of priority.
Full paper reference
Hoffmann, V., Paul, B., Falade, T., Moodley, A., Ramankutty, N., Olawoye, J., Djouaka, R., Lekei, E., de Haan, N., Ballantyne, P. , Waage, J., ‘A one health approach to plant health,’ CABI Agric Biosci 29 September (2022). DOI: 10.1186/s43170-022-00118-2
The paper can be read open access from 00:01hrs UK time 29 September 2022 here: https://cabiagbio.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s43170-022-00118-2
Wayne Coles, Communications Manager, CABI – email: email@example.com
Dr Vivian Hoffmann, Senior Research Fellow at the International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) – email: V.Hoffmann@cgiar.org
About CABI Agriculture and Bioscience
CABI Agriculture and Bioscience (CABI A&B) publishes high quality, rigorously peer-reviewed multi-, inter- and transdisciplinary research focused on agriculture, food security, and the environment.
Global agriculture faces many challenges today. How can we produce more safe, nutritious food in the face of climate change? Can we balance greater efficiencies with the need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and protect biodiversity? Can we meet changing market demands and yet develop more equitable growth? Can agriculture provide a livelihood and opportunities for women and young people?
These problems require complex and urgent solutions from researchers and policymakers. That is why CABI A&B is committed to encouraging an inclusive culture of scientific discussion and rapid information sharing among researchers worldwide. We publish both large and incremental advances in science in both primary and multidisciplinary fields across the biosciences, agriculture, agronomy, microbiology, social sciences, and the environment.
CABI A&B is an open access journal, with rapid peer review, making findings immediately available to all readers worldwide. We believe it will help engender a clearer understanding of facts and findings, and help challenge assumptions.